Eoghan Harris identified in the latest edition of the Sunday Independent what he termed 'the thin veil' of tolerance and of pluralism in the Irish Republic. For, as we all know, increasing prosperity does not necessarily equal enlightened values. Let me put the facts on the table:
This was not specifically a Love Ulster parade. It was a parade by British members of the Northern Ireland community, supported by Love Ulster and the Orange Order, to commemorate Unionist victims of the IRA murder campaign to effectively achieve by genocide what the Irish Consitution claimed was a destination of legal right and constitutional imperative. Why should they have commemorated all victims? Up until this year, the perennial Bloody Sunday whingers couldn't give a fiddlers about victims other than their own transgressive rabble. Did anyone ever condemn them for that?
So, for the purposes of ATW readers, I am going to republish some of the comments made by Oirish people from both within and without the Irish State (to evince opinion in what the Consitution now terms the 'Irish Nation'). What's more, these people will be readers of that country's most liberal newspaper. Let's see just how enlightened the average Paddy is.
'What were the Government Ministers and the police thinking about when this march was given the go ahead?
F.A.I.R has a lot to answer for in so far as provoking this terror on the streets in Dublin. Maybe the Government Ministers have now learnt a lesson by seeing such a beautiful city centre lying in ruins, not to mention the dreadful injuries meted out.'
Doctor Rosaleen O'Brien, Luton, UK
'Despite Saturday's disturbances in Dublin caused by dissident Republicans, the full implementation of the Good Friday Agreement is still the best hope for peace and justice in both parts of Ireland.
The Agreement attempts to deal with the causes of injustice in the North, which in some cases, have existed since Partition was imposed in 1920.
This agreement, at least to some extent, recognises the obvious fact that 45 per cent of the Six County population considers itself Irish and desire to be part of one Irish nation that would zealously protect the rights of Loyalists who are still the majority in two of Ireland's 32 counties.'
Sean MacCurtain, Franklin, USA
'As someone who holds traditionalist Republican views (i.e. not those of modern Sinn Fein), I would like to point out that I distance myself completely from what happened in Dublin on Saturday.
I witnessed the riots, but was not involved - a violent reaction to Loyalist provocation was exactly what Willie Frazer and his entourage of dolled-up UDA men were looking for.'
Michea O'Haodha, Baile Atha Luain, RoI
'FAIR's reason for marching would not be looked at.
Genuine voices of protest would not be heard.
Love Ulster is an anti-Agreement campaign that sought to lobby southern opinion by hiding behind the dead. The violence witnessed on the streets of Dublin allowed them to go unchallenged.
FAIR's Love Ulster tour is not about victims, or achieving closure for their relatives. The Love Ulster campaign wants to turn back the clock to the good old days, before civil rights, a time where the taigs knew their place and the B-Specials roamed wild and free.'
Cahal McCarthy, Limerick, RoI
'What are we coming to? Could republicans parade through London, and not expect trouble? Be it right or wrong, it would be a fool to think there would be no trouble in Dublin on Sat.'
Cormac, RoI
'They should not be allowed march in the Republic anywhere at all. Let the government confine the madness of NI riots to north of the border even if that means abridging freedom of expression. For too many people south of the border the sight of Lambeg drums and marching bands has too much of an air of unionist triumphalism about it, a touch too much of croppy lie down etc which has plagued nationalists lives for too long. It didn't take a rocket scientist to predict that trouble would occur at such an event south of the border. Unless the Gardai can police such events effectively, which they can't, they shouldn't be allowed.'
John, Dublin, RoI
'I do not think the loyalists should be allowed to march simply because it was just an excuse to antagonise nationalists in the first place. This is no excuse for what happened.'
Maura, RoI
'As an Irish citizen I find it appalling that loyalists should be allowed to hold a march in my country. Most of the people who inhabit the province of Ulster have a deep hatred of the Republic and would jump at the chance to cause mayham in our capital city.'
Noel, RoI
'Yes, of course they should still be allowed to march. There is a long and deep tradition of loyalists marching to provoke violence and to break ceasefires by effectively marching over the graves of Irish dead. These agents provocateurs are only lucky that the Gardai are trained differently to the RUC - otherwise the protesters might have been given free rein and the organisers of Love Ulster subsequently shot!!'
Garry, Galway, RoI
'No way should loyalists be allowed march through Dublin or any part Ireland,all loyalist marching are about triumphalism and hatred, if we let these loyalists march through our country maybe we should welcome Bin Laden and Al Quieda to do some marching'
James, RoI
'I don't think the Loyalist's should be allowed to march through Dublin, it would be similar to letting the KKK march through New York or Washington fully decked out in all there ceremonial uniform. The treatment of the Catholics in NI bears so many similarities with the treatment of black Americans in the south; indeed the nationalist protesting in NI was sparked off from the civil rights marches in the southern states. It is no use saying this was in the past, as the loyalist tradition and marching bands is all about keeping down the nationalists and ensuring they stay second class citizens in their own country, this has not changed.'
Larry, RoI
'Either way, the unionists should not have been allowed to march. Marching in itself is provocative, so in effect they got what they came for. Too many Irish lives have been destroyed under British rule in the past and with REAL apologies still outstanding and attacks on the Irish President still continuing, we as a nation should not be giving those who despise our country a platform. If genuine people, victims of violence want to march for peace, then let them march, but let the drums and pipes behind you. And to all Irish people, don't be ashamed of the word Republican. It is after all what the great Irish men and women who built this country strived for, so don't let Bertie and the prostitute government of Ireland tell you any different, as they go begging bowl in hand for a few dollars more.'
NJ
'I don't have much respect for the Orange Order as it is a sectarian, bigoted organisation.'
Mary Harney, Tanaiste, RoI
As I've said previously, and am happy to repeat, beneath the wafer-thin veneer of 'top of the mornin' to ya,' 'come on in and 'av a pint o' Porter', 'God Bliss ya and the Divil miss ya', and 'when Oirish eyes are smilin' there remains a deep-seated dislike of any manifestations of Britishness - be it our flag, our Royal Family or the right of our citizens to protest at their treatment by that country's foreign and interfering government: a government in breach of international law and protocol for over 60 years in backing a Constitutional claim which gave rise to the terrorism responsible for taking the loved ones of those people who desired to highlight that message on Saturday. And the above represent the theme of the clear majority of responses in Ireland's most broad-minded media publication. Says a lot about the types who dwell on Erin's sod. Maybe the greeting signs should say:
'Welcome to Oireland. Ceid Mille Fimíneach'.
Recent Comments